Dialects: Where Nuanced Thoughts Strive to Survive

Dialects: Where Nuanced Thoughts Strive to Survive
Photo by Firdaus Roslan on Unsplash.

WHEN I’M ASKED to explain the Kelantanese Malay dialect, I often begin with a listening trick. I say two phrases: ikan makan kucing and ikan makan kkucing (with a sharp emphasis on the “k”). On paper, they look identical. But to Kelantanese ears, the meaning flips: in the first, the fish eats the cat; in the second, the cat eats the fish. A tiny shift in stress transforms the meaning of the whole sentence. To me, this captures what Kelantanese dialect really is—not just vocabulary or accent, but a rhythm of thought and feeling that lives in tones and cadences.

I grew up in Kelantan in the 90s, speaking this obscure dialect every day—at home, in my kampung, at the pasar malam. To me, it is the language of jokes, quarrels, lullabies and gossip. It carries dikir barat, wayang kulit and mak yong—traditions whose wit and music only come alive in Kelantanese Malay. I remember watching a dikir barat performance on TV that was performed by Singaporeans in Standard Malay; the rhythm was intact, and the costumes were faithful to tradition, yet the soul was missing.

Read the full story

Sign up now for FREE to access all articles.

Register
Already have an account? Sign in
Great! Next, complete checkout for full access to Penang Monthly.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to Penang Monthly.
Success! Your account is fully activated, you now have access to all content.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.